WHY MIKEL ARTETA RISKED ARSENAL’S QUADRUPLE ON KEPA ARRIZABALAGA’S CUP LOYALTY
Jamie Carragher criticizes Mikel Arteta for starting Kepa Arrizabalaga over David Raya in Arsenal's 2-0 cup loss.
Jamie Carragher has voiced criticism of Mikel Arteta’s choice to stick with Kepa Arrizabalaga for the Carabao Cup final, especially after the Arsenal keeper’s error paved the way for Man City’s opening goal. At Wembley, Kepa failed to hold onto a cross from Rayan Cherki, which allowed Nico O'Reilly to score around the 60th minute. Not long after, O’Reilly doubled the lead for City, who held on to their 2-0 advantage and claimed their first domestic trophy of the season.
Despite this, Arteta stood by Kepa’s selection over David Raya, his usual first-choice keeper, saying he would make the same decision again. Kepa had been trusted throughout Arsenal’s run to the final, but Carragher wasn’t convinced this was the right call. Speaking on Sky Sports, the former Liverpool defender argued that Arteta had underestimated what was at stake: ending a long trophy drought for the Gunners.
Carragher expressed a clear dislike for playing the second-choice keeper in such important matches but admitted he could see when it might be acceptable. Still, his main point was that Arteta owes the fans the best possible chance of winning, especially considering Arsenal have only picked up one trophy in almost a decade. He sees the role of a backup goalkeeper as someone who can help in earlier rounds, but believes the final demands the strongest lineup.
“Playing the second goalkeeper in the final doesn’t make sense when the club hasn’t won enough trophies,” Carragher said. “Arsenal needs to do everything to finish the job, and that means putting in its best players, regardless of previous arrangements. The loyalty should be to the supporters more than to Kepa.”
Carragher also drew comparisons with Man City’s approach. Pep Guardiola started James Trafford over Gianluigi Donnarumma in the final, and despite Kepa’s error, Carragher saw a key difference. He argued that Guardiola owed Trafford a chance because he was originally signed to be the first-choice before being replaced mid-season, and the pressure on City to win wasn’t as pressing given their recent success.
“The situation with Trafford is distinct,” Carragher explained. “He came in for that role, but Donnarumma arrived as a late upgrade. Plus, Man City has won this competition several times recently, so the urgency isn’t comparable.”
He also mentioned players like Liverpool’s Caoimhin Kelleher, who was trusted in finals because the club was determined to keep him, highlighting that Kepa’s background is different; he joined as a backup and hasn’t quite proven he’s at the top level, something Arsene Wenger hinted at during his Chelsea days as well.
Carragher emphasised that swapping Kepa for Raya isn’t a simple No. 2-for-No. 1 change. He pointed out that Raya has arguably been Arsenal’s standout player this season, so leaving him out for a crucial final means benching one of the team’s best, which is a risky move given their recent lack of silverware.
Arteta, meanwhile, defended his decision by noting that he never promised Kepa a spot in all cup games but acknowledged the Spaniard had earned his place through his performances up to the final. He said errors are part of football, and, though unfortunate, this one came at a crucial moment.
“I have to be honest and fair,” Arteta said after the match. “Kepa played every game in this competition so far, and changing that now wouldn’t have been right for him or the team. Players have to earn their place, and based on what Kepa showed during this run, I believe keeping him was the right call.”
WHAT IS THE "AURA" MIKEL ARTETA SEES IN BUKAYO SAKA’S RECENT PERFORMANCES?
"He shifts momentum." Read Mikel Arteta’s full analysis of Bukayo Saka’s importance ahead of the crucial West Ham showdown.
Mikel Arteta sees something special in Bukayo Saka’s presence on the pitch, an “aura” that he believes could drive Arsenal toward a Premier League title, just three games away from ending a 22-year wait.
During Saka’s recent absence with an Achilles injury, Arsenal managed only a single win in five matches. His return, however, seemed to breathe new life into the squad. Saka set up Viktor Gyokeres for the opener before scoring himself in a solid 3-0 victory over Fulham last weekend.
More crucially, Saka netted the decisive goal that helped Arsenal secure a 2-1 aggregate win over Atlético Madrid, booking their first Champions League final appearance since 2006.
Since making his debut for the Gunners seven years ago, the England international now carries the hopes of pushing Arsenal for vital points, starting with a key clash against relegation-threatened West Ham at the London Stadium, followed by matches against Burnley at home and Crystal Palace away on the season’s final day.
When asked about Saka’s importance, Arteta highlighted the growing role he plays not just within the team but also in how opponents see him. There’s a clear presence, a certain quality that sets him apart. According to Arteta, Saka can shift a game’s momentum at any time, and instilling that kind of respect or even fear in the opposition is invaluable.
Arteta also touched on managing Saka’s comeback after injury, emphasising the idea of channelling fresh energy and motivation into his performance rather than rushing him back too soon. He described it as a privilege to have a player like Saka, someone who embodies core values and principles, both on and off the pitch. Beyond the football, there’s a human connection that makes working with him rewarding. What Saka showed, especially in the recent Champions League semifinal, was nothing short of remarkable.
Alongside Saka, Declan Rice has also become a pivotal figure since his £100 million move from West Ham last year. Now 27, Rice will make his 59th appearance of the season when Arsenal faces his former club on Sunday. His impact has been significant, earning him runner-up in the Football Writers’ Association Footballer of the Year award behind Bruno Fernandes.
Arteta praised Rice as a key leader and a major force for the team, underlining the powerful role he plays as Arsenal chase success this season.
WHY DID JURRIEN TIMBER’S "SIMPLE" INJURY TURN INTO A SEASON-ENDING MEDICAL MYSTERY?
After reaching the Champions League final, Arsenal face a fitness race for key stars ahead of their clash with West Ham.
Mikel Arteta has admitted that both Mikel Merino and Jurrien Timber are running out of time to get fit before the season ends – a tough setback for Arsenal right now.
Both have been out for weeks, dealing with foot and ankle injuries. The hope was always that they’d be back for the final stretch, giving Arsenal a boost when it matters most. This week, Merino at least made it back onto the training pitch, but Arteta has confirmed neither he nor Timber will be involved in Sunday’s big match against West Ham.
Arteta said he has no new injury problems elsewhere, but for Merino or Timber to play before the end of the season, their recoveries would have to be almost perfect. Timber’s situation in particular has turned out to be more complicated than they first thought.
“That’s probably been the hardest part for everyone. For me, for the player,” Arteta said. “We really didn’t think it would take this long, and he’s still not ready.”
Meanwhile, things are going well for Arsenal on the pitch. They’ve pulled five points clear at the top of the Premier League, and they just beat Atletico Madrid, booking a spot in their first Champions League final in two decades.
There’s still a twist, though. Manchester City play Brentford first this weekend, and they still have a game in hand. Even so, if Arsenal win their last three matches, the title is theirs.
Next up is West Ham, who are fighting to avoid relegation and could easily trip Arsenal up. Arteta knows his team can’t afford any slip-ups. “After the Atletico win, I was completely caught up in the emotion. You could feel what it meant to everyone fans and the staff. But straight after, my focus went to West Ham,” he said.
“We talked as a team about how we’ve earned the chance to be in the final, and we have time to get ready, but right now, all our focus and all the details need to go into West Ham.”
