REFEREES IN RUINS: WHY ALAN SHEARER THINKS VAR HAS KILLED ON-FIELD DECISION MAKING

Newcastle 3-1 Villa: Read why Alan Shearer and Wayne Rooney are furious over the "shambolic" officiating at a VAR-less Villa Park.

Referees In Ruins: Why Alan Shearer Thinks VAR Has Killed On-Field Decision Making
Alan Shearer Is Right—Referees Are Now Petrified Without Their Technology

Alan Shearer was fuming after a string of questionable calls in Newcastle United’s FA Cup win against Aston Villa, and now a former PGMOL chief has his back. VAR wasn’t in play for any of the fourth-round matches, not even at Premier League grounds, and honestly, you could feel its absence at Villa Park. Newcastle pushed through to round five with a 3-1 win, but the drama around the officiating just wouldn’t quit.

Tammy Abraham’s opening goal for Villa instantly set everyone off. Replays showed he was offside, but the flag stayed down. Then things got messier. Newcastle should’ve had a penalty when Lucas Digne clearly handled the ball in the box, but the referee gave them a free kick instead. Digne also dodged a red card for a nasty high challenge on Jacob Murphy again; the officials let him off easy.

Referee Chris Kavanagh didn’t see Digne’s wild tackle as worthy of a sending off, but Keith Hackett, who used to run the Professional Game Match Officials Board, didn’t hold back. “The challenge by Digne should have received a red card,” he said. “It was clear serious foul play.” Hackett also called out other decisions that went against Newcastle, saying they flat-out got them wrong.

When asked about the missed penalty, Hackett couldn’t hide his frustration. “Oh dear. Referee Chris Kavanagh really should have received appropriate intervention by the assistant to advise that it was in the penalty area,” he told Football Insider.

After the match, Shearer tore into the officiating, especially assistant referee Nick Greenhalgh. “There was maybe a small excuse for the referee to miss that the handball was in the box, and I’m being generous, but there’s no excuse at all for the assistant, who was 10 or 15 yards away,” Shearer said.

He didn’t hold back. “Greenhalgh had an absolute nightmare today. If you ever needed proof of the damage VAR’s done to referees, today’s it. These guys looked terrified to make decisions without their safety net. That’s the damage VAR has done to officials. They’re getting worse, not better. This wasn’t a tough call; it was easy. At this level, you have to give it. There’s no excuse for the assistant not to tell the referee. He got it totally wrong.”

Wayne Rooney, working alongside Shearer for the BBC, was just as angry about the missed penalty. “That decision is one of the worst I’ve ever seen in football,” he said. “Digne was never outside the box; he’s three or four yards inside. The linesman’s right there. You can see exactly where Digne is. The referee blew his whistle and looked like he was listening to someone in his ear, so I’m guessing the linesman made the call, and it’s an absolute shocker.”

SCOTT PARKER OPENS UP ABOUT THE "HEARTBREAKING" DIVIDE BETWEEN HIM AND BURNLEY FANS

Scott Parker opens up about his uncertain Burnley future and the "painful" relationship with fans as relegation looms in 2026.

top-news
Scott Parker admits he may be a hindrance as relegation looms large - Courtesy Picture

Scott Parker opened up about the uncertainty surrounding his future at Burnley and the increasingly strained relationship he has with the club’s supporters, especially with relegation looming.

Burnley’s fate could be sealed as soon as tomorrow night with a loss to Manchester City at Turf Moor, an outcome that would officially confirm their drop.

Before that crucial match, Parker faced questions about whether he still sees himself at Burnley next season and how he’s been dealing with the tension from the fans, which has at times bordered on outright hostility during this tough campaign.

Here’s a glimpse of what he shared:

On being booed after the Forest game

“I try to be straightforward and fair, and after the weekend, I completely get the boos we earned them. The confusion the fans must have felt is something I felt too. For about 60 minutes, it looked like we were in control, everything going to plan; then, within half an hour, the game just slipped away, and we lost 4-1.

“That kind of frustration and not understanding how things unravel like that, it sticks with us. So yeah, the boos made sense to me.

“There are other moments where I genuinely don’t know why the reaction is so negative, where boos feel a bit disconnected from what’s happening on the pitch.

“I recognise in football now it’s become something of a trend; anytime the opposition scores or at halftime if you’re trailing, the instant reaction from some is to boo. It’s like fans are bracing for disappointment at every turn.

“But in this instance, I accept it fully and never judge that reaction. If I were in their shoes, watching our team like that, I probably would feel the same.

“We let ourselves down badly for that half-hour stretch, and we’ve had moments like that during the season.”

On understanding the fans who pay to watch

“That message is constant every time we prepare, every time we finish a meeting; it’s the same: these fans are spending their hard-earned money, coming to our stadium, and our responsibility is to give absolutely everything on the pitch.

“They might forgive occasional mistakes, but what they won’t accept is a lack of effort.

“I know there’s been doubt during the season about whether we’re giving it our all. I can assure you, the players are pushing themselves to the limit.

“Sometimes the quality wasn’t there, sure, but treating effort as a question mark has been a recurring theme.

“We play not just for ourselves but for the fans supporting us across the country and for those showing up in the stands.

“Sometimes we haven’t delivered on that, and of course I get why people get frustrated, but that’s what we keep trying to fix.”

On whether he wants to stay next season

“This season has been hugely challenging. Last year, I faced big hurdles too, though back then we were winning and enjoying success. Challenges come with the territory.

“Right now, my focus, like everyone else’s, is on the final five games of this season.

“Where the club goes from here, and what the future holds, that's something we’ll talk about at the appropriate time.”

On winning back the fans’ trust

“That’s the biggest hurdle for me. I fully acknowledge that my relationship with the fans isn’t where it should be.

“Honestly, the way to win them back is simple: winning games. That’s true for any manager in this position.

“What I can say is that since arriving 18 months ago, I’ve dedicated myself fully. I’m often the first to arrive and last to leave. I’ve made sacrifices: family life and a young son relocating to a new school, all for the sake of this club and my career.

“This season hasn’t gone well, and I’m the one who often gets the blame. There are reasons why and reasons why not, but I own my part.

“These fans have values that mirror my own. I’ve left no stone unturned in trying to help the club succeed. Sometimes, perhaps too much.

“The difference from last year is that we succeeded then; this year, as a club, we have not.

“My ambition remains to win back the fans because I know how vital their support is for the players and for the club. If I ever feel I’m more of a hindrance than a help, then I’ll understand that too.”

On whether the sacrifices have been hard to bear

“The sacrifices last year were no different, even during a record-breaking unbeaten run and impressive point total.

“This year has brought new challenges, probably the toughest I’ve faced in my coaching career.

“One of the hardest parts has been the relationship with the fans.

“I played football for 20 years, experienced relegation a few times, and endured poor performances, but the one constant was that fans always appreciated how I played. That’s who I am.

“It’s painful that for some fans, that feeling hasn’t been there this year.

“Still, I recognise that this kind of scrutiny and reaction is the norm in modern football, though I’d like to change it if I can.”

On accepting responsibility and spreading it across the club

“Oh, absolutely, the responsibility isn’t mine alone. I wouldn’t try to dodge it, though; I take full accountability as manager.

“But the club as a whole carries some of this burden.

“We’re facing tough realities as a club with limited resources; the challenge this year has been steep.

“I’ve said before, we needed to punch above our weight, and sometimes that just isn’t possible.

“Investment is limited, and that’s a fact that can’t be ignored.

“I carry the majority of the responsibility, but it’s something that runs throughout the ownership, the players, and the staff as well.

“We’ve just come up short this year. At times, we let ourselves down. It hasn’t been consistent over many games, but the fact remains.”

GABRIEL SARA EYES PREMIER LEAGUE RETURN AS TRANSFER RUMORS REACH A BOILING POINT

Aston Villa and Newcastle scouts are set to watch Gabriel Sara in the derby. Discover the €30m asking price and his Premier League links.

top-news
Galatasaray sets a firm €30 million minimum asking price for Gabriel Sara - Photo Credit: Getty Images

Aston Villa and Newcastle United are preparing to keep a close watch on Gabriel Sara, Galatasaray’s key midfielder, during their upcoming derby against Fenerbahce. Sara’s steady performances have earned him recognition, and several top clubs have him on their radar.

Sporx reports that both Premier League teams will have scouts present at Rams Park on April 26 to assess Sara’s impact in this high-profile match. The way he performs in this fixture could influence whether these clubs decide to move forward with a transfer.

After impressing at Norwich City in the English second division, Sara was brought to Galatasaray in the summer of 2024. Since then, he’s become a mainstay in their lineup, appearing in 87 matches and contributing to 23 goals for the Turkish side. Though mainly a central midfielder, he adapts well to various midfield roles. This season alone, he’s played 42 games and been involved in 11 goals.

At 26, Sara not only helps dictate the rhythm of the game but also poses a threat going forward. His performances have caught enough attention for him to break into the Brazilian national team, putting him in consideration for the World Cup squad.

Looking ahead, Sara’s current contract with Galatasaray runs until 2029, but Newcastle and Aston Villa might pursue him this summer. Newcastle, facing some uncertainty around Sandro Tonali, sees Sara as a potential reinforcement for their midfield, while Unai Emery at Villa is aiming to boost quality in central areas, especially with Ross Barkley likely to leave.

However, bringing Sara to the Premier League won’t be straightforward. Galatasaray values him at around €22 million but isn’t keen on selling for less than €30 million. With his long-term contract, the club holds firm control over his future, so any transfer would require careful negotiation.

Read More News