DAVID MOYES SLAMS "EMBARRASSING" VAR AFTER MICHAEL KEANE APPEAL IS REJECTED
David Moyes attacks "bizarre" FA ruling on Michael Keane's hair-pull red card. Get the full scoop on the Everton boss's outburst.
David Moyes didn’t hold back after Everton lost their appeal over Michael Keane’s red card. Keane got sent off—thanks to a VAR review—for pulling Tolu Arokodare’s hair during an aerial challenge late in the game against Wolves. Everton tried to overturn the decision on Thursday, but the FA panel shot them down. So, Keane’s out for the next three matches.
Everton put out a statement confirming the bad news just before Moyes faced the press ahead of their FA Cup clash with Sunderland. The club said they were “disappointed,” but Moyes went much further. He was furious, especially after watching Gabriel Martinelli get away with just a yellow for shoving an injured Conor Bradley off the pitch during Arsenal’s 0-0 draw with Liverpool the night before.
“Hugely disappointed. Hugely surprised. Honestly, I’m more angry with the panel who thought that was the right call,” Moyes said. “I know exactly who was on that panel. I can’t believe none of them overturned it. Are they calling that violent conduct?
“Last night, you could throw a ball at someone, push them, or even pick up a player who’s clearly hurt, and that’s fine. But Keane accidentally pulls someone’s hair and gets a three-match ban? That’s just bizarre to me.”
Moyes kept going: “He shouldn’t be banned at all. Honestly, I’m embarrassed for whoever’s running VAR. You’ve got a young ref doing maybe his third or fourth game, and VAR dropped him in it with a terrible call.
“What Keane did somehow gets him three games and a red card, but there was another tackle in that game that was much worse, and VAR didn’t even look at it. Feels like they’re getting everything backwards right now.”
He didn’t stop there. On Keane’s situation, Moyes added, “I’m just saying what I think. If I talk too much, they’ll just fine me for speaking out of turn. But if they want us to come on TV and talk, we should at least be able to tell the truth. That’s how I see it.
“Maybe it sounds like I’m saying there’s inconsistency, and honestly, I don’t have a huge issue with that. I just want them to do their jobs as well as possible. But if this is their best, then they’re in trouble.”
The chaos didn’t end with Keane. Jack Grealish also saw red against Rob Edwards’ side—two yellows for dissent in three minutes at the end of the match.
Moyes admitted he originally thought Grealish was out of line for clapping the ref, but then he saw clips of other players doing the same thing and not getting booked.
He said, “I wasn’t going to talk about the other decisions—they’re in the past, and there’s no point. But now that you mention it, I realise there have been a few more calls that went against us recently, and they’re tough to take.
“I thought Grealish was wrong at first, but then I saw other players clap the ref and get away with it—no booking, no sending off. We’ve seen handballs waved away, too. Now that you bring it up, yeah, there have been a few decisions that have definitely gone against Everton.”
LONDON DERBY: CHELSEA AND TOTTENHAM TO BATTLE FOR BAYERN’S KIM MIN-JAE THIS SUMMER
Kim Min-Jae is back on the radar! Discover why Chelsea and Tottenham are racing to sign the Bayern Munich defender this summer.
Are Chelsea and Tottenham about to scrap over a top defender this summer? It’s not out of the question.
Both clubs have different priorities right now, but things could get interesting if Bayern Munich decide to let Kim Min-Jae go. That would put two London rivals on a collision course, each desperate for defensive reinforcements.
Chelsea, under Liam Rosenior, appears to be a different team, boasting eight wins from eleven games in all competitions. Rosenior’s barely had time to settle in, and he’s already been tested on four fronts. They’re hungry, and the mood around Stamford Bridge has shifted.
Tottenham, though, are in a very different place. They’re flirting with the relegation zone, and this time the threat feels real. West Ham, Leeds, and Forest are all clawing for survival. Spurs have Igor Tudor in charge until the end of the season, and managing in England for the first time while juggling a pile of injuries isn’t exactly a dream start. If they stay up, and right now, that’s still a big "if", they’ll need to strengthen fast.
That’s where Kim Min-Jae comes in. Both Chelsea and Spurs are eyeing him up, according to reports. Bayern paid £43 million to bring him in from Napoli last year, making him the most expensive Asian player ever. He helped Napoli win the Scudetto before that, and he’s won titles in Germany and South Korea, too. The guy knows how to get over the line.
But things haven’t clicked at Bayern. Kim was excellent in their 3-0 win over Bremen last weekend, but he’s mostly been third-choice behind Upamecano and Tah. Ten Bundesliga starts, just two in the Champions League. Not exactly what he signed up for. Bayern insider Christian Falk says Chelsea and Spurs have both shown interest, and Kim’s on their shortlist. Liverpool have been linked to, but right now, it’s the London clubs circling.
Chelsea have a hole at the back ever since Thiago Silva moved on. Kim, at 29, would instantly become the oldest player in the squad – not a bad thing for a team packed with young talent that sometimes looks a bit lost under pressure. They need his experience.
Spurs, on the other hand, have a solid pairing with Van de Ven and Romero, but if they lose one, things get thin pretty fast. Kim would be an upgrade on their depth and could slot straight into the starting eleven. And let’s be honest, the Son Heung-min effect is real. Kim would draw huge support from South Korea, just like Son has.
Kim isn’t agitating for a move just yet, but if Bayern decide to cash in and the right offer lands on the table, don’t be surprised to see him in the Premier League next season. Whether it’s in blue or white, that’s the part nobody knows yet.
PGMOL SIDELINES CHRIS KAVANAGH AS REFEREEING STANDARDS COME UNDER INTENSE SCRUTINY
Chris Kavanagh won't referee this weekend! Analyse the PGMOL decision and Wayne Rooney’s "worst ever" handball claim at Villa Park.
Chris Kavanagh won’t be refereeing any Premier League games this weekend, and honestly, that’s no surprise after all the drama in last Saturday’s Aston Villa vs Newcastle FA Cup match.
Kavanagh and his assistants, Gary Beswick and Nick Greenhalgh, got hammered by critics for how they handled that fourth-round tie at Villa Park. There was no VAR in play; none of the matches in that round had it, so the officials had to make the big calls themselves.
They missed Tammy Abraham standing offside for Villa’s first goal. Then Lucas Digne put in a high challenge on Newcastle’s Jacob Murphy, the sort of tackle that usually gets a red card, but nothing happened. Later, Digne got penalised for a handball, but he was clearly inside the box, and somehow the ref gave a free-kick outside instead.
This weekend, Beswick is working as an assistant for the Nottingham Forest vs Liverpool game on Sunday, but Kavanagh and Greenhalgh are nowhere to be seen on the official appointments list.
Referees are judged on their performances. The Professional Game Match Officials (PGMOL) decide who gets which games based on a bunch of factors, including independent assessments after each match.
Still, Kavanagh is well-regarded among refs. He just made it onto UEFA’s top officials list and often gets Champions League matches. Earlier on Monday, Wayne Rooney chimed in and said the mistakes from Saturday showed just how much refs have come to rely on VAR.
On BBC’s live coverage that night, Rooney called the handball decision “one of the worst” he’d ever seen. Later, on his podcast, he said, “I think there’s over-reliance on VAR. Now the officials are used to it; they wait for VAR to bail them out. With no VAR, they have to make the call themselves, and they’re so used to keeping the flag down that it cost them yesterday.”
Graham Scott, who used to referee in the Premier League, joined the podcast too. He pushed back against the idea that refs hide behind VAR. “I work with them closely; I know these guys, and they’re not like that,” Scott said. “That’s not how they think or work. I spent half my career with VAR and half without it – well, actually, without it first. Even when I was in the Premier League, I’d sometimes ref in the Championship with no VAR. You’re in and out, but your process doesn’t really change.”
VAR comes back for the FA Cup from the fifth round. In the Premier League, officials are told to trust their own judgement. The English top flight actually has the lowest rate of VAR interventions in Europe’s major leagues. Here, they only overturn a call if it’s clearly and obviously wrong.