StadiumPosts Logo
Stay upto date with notifications from Stadiumposts
Notifications can be managed in browser preferences

CARLOS SAINZ SLAMS "UNACCEPTABLE" OSCAR PIASTRI PENALTY AS FAR FROM GOOD

Carlos Sainz slams "unacceptable" F1 stewarding after Oscar Piastri's Brazil GP penalty. The Ferrari driver demands clearer, more consistent rules for overtaking and racing incidents.

Carlos Sainz  Slams "Unacceptable" Oscar Piastri Penalty as Far From Good
Sainz Echoes Concerns Now

After Oscar Piastri received a penalty during the Sao Paulo Grand Prix, Carlos Sainz expressed strong criticism of the stewarding in Formula 1 and called for clearer guidelines regarding overtaking.

At the restart following a Virtual Safety Car period in Interlagos, the McLaren driver was handed a 10-second time penalty after colliding with Andrea Kimi Antonelli's Mercedes.

As Piastri and Antonelli approached Turn 1, their contact triggered a chain reaction that led to Charles Leclerc retiring from the race after being hit by Antonelli.

The Australian maintained that he did not warrant a punishment, while Leclerc noted that Antonelli also bore some responsibility.

This season, Sainz has faced his fair share of penalties for similar incidents, including a highly disputed collision with Liam Lawson at the Dutch Grand Prix.

Ahead of this weekend's Las Vegas Grand Prix, the Spaniard emphasised the need for greater clarity. That particular penalty was later overturned.

Addressing the media, including Motorsport Week, he remarked, "I think we need an immediate meeting to address this issue, because in my opinion, it’s unacceptable that Oscar received a penalty in Brazil."

"Honestly, we occupy the pinnacle of motorsport in our category.

"I think everyone witnessed what transpired, so there’s no need for me to elaborate. It’s clear to anyone who has watched racing that this was not Oscar’s fault, and anyone who has actually driven a race car understands he had no means of averting that incident, yet he was still given a 10-second penalty, which I find incomprehensible."

"I couldn’t grasp why Oli was penalised during our crash in Monza, nor did I understand my penalty at Zandvoort. I told him directly after the race that he didn’t deserve that punishment.

"There have been several instances this year that, in my view, are far from where the sport should stand. I couldn’t fathom how I received a 10-second penalty in Austin and then faced issues in Brazil."

Sainz opined that "effective stewardship" could aid F1 drivers in determining who is at fault.

Currently, stewards operate at races in groups of three under Race Director Rui Marques’s guidance.

Sainz suggested that if the structure were adjusted to have a consistent trio at each Grand Prix, it would lead to more precise rules for drivers.

"With consistent and effective stewardship, along with a deep understanding of racing, we would cultivate a common understanding over the course of the year, allowing us to better identify faults, both our own and those of others. That's how I view the situation," he stated.

"I genuinely believe that if we had three fixed individuals, akin to having a designated Race Director, we would develop a kind of muscle memory regarding how they typically assess penalties or choose not to impose them, allowing us to understand their longstanding approach to penalties.

"I truly believe that even without explicit rules, one can recognise when someone is at fault or when it simply constitutes a racing incident."

FIGHTING FERRARI FIRMLY FREE FROM THE LEWIS HAMILTON QUALI CONFUSION LOSS

Analysis of Lewis Hamilton's costly Q1 error at the Las Vegas GP. Jenson Button & Bernie Collins explain the confusion between the timing line and red lights that led to him aborting his final lap.

top-news
No Blame For Ferrari

Jenson Button and Bernie Collins have expressed their backing for Ferrari following the "confusion" that arose during Lewis Hamilton's last attempt in Q1 at the Las Vegas Grand Prix.

The seven-time F1 champion decided to halt what might have been his final lap, mistakenly thinking he hadn't reached the timing line in time to commence a new lap, as indicated by the red lights on his dashboard.

This decision resulted in him finishing in P20, last on the grid, after clocking the slowest time in the rain-drenched first qualifying session in Las Vegas.

For the first time in his F1 career, Hamilton will line up at the back due to his pace, having prematurely exited from a crucial final chance.

It quickly became clear that he had erred amid the chaos and poor conditions, but given that he had faced a yellow flag shortly before and had briefly contacted a bollard with his SF-25, he believed it wouldn't have significantly altered his performance.

Button, who was once Hamilton's teammate at McLaren, stressed the importance of continuing to push until advised to do otherwise, which the 105-time race winner failed to do.

"Continue until you're told to slow down," the 2009 F1 champion stated on Sky Sports F1.

"You should be aware of all the rules. It can be very challenging for a driver, especially when red lights appear in front of you, giving the impression that it's finished.

"However, the timing line is before that point, and he should know this since his dashboard displays the time for the previous lap.

"In such difficult conditions, with so many distractions, he may have been relieved that it seemed over, but he lost sight of what he needed to do for his next lap."

Was Hamilton to blame?


When it was mentioned that the Ferrari pit wall would have been aware of the tight situation, Button responded, "But they can't assume he understands that the timing line differs from the red light gantry," clarifying that the timing line and start/finish line are located at different spots.

Collins defended Riccardo Adami, Hamilton's race engineer, pointing out that he made efforts to ensure his driver did not lift off the throttle.

"I just wanted to add to that a bit. I was trying to catch it during the commentary, and I listened again when Lewis went out, as it was evident from the radio that there was some confusion regarding the light," Collins mentioned.

"On the lap prior, the one where he was approaching the line, the pit wall informed him that it would be closed for one more lap, urging him to keep pushing for another attempt.
This serves as a clear signal to a driver: first, that you’re not in a safe position if they urge you to push for another lap; secondly, that it's close to the limit, but they believe it's feasible, or they wouldn't suggest it.

"He received that message earlier in the lab. Then, as he approaches the line, Lewis inquires, "Am, am I secure?"

"His engineer responds, saying, 'No, keep up the pace.'" Lewis then says, 'I say, "I see the light, light; I see the red light."' The engineer reiterates, 'No, keep going.' reiterates, 'No,''

"However, by that moment, it’s already too late. He had initially been informed—though I didn’t review everything—prior to reaching the line that it would be tight and he needed to maintain his speed.

"When he saw the red light, he thought perhaps Ferrari miscalculated the timing, or he hadn’t completed the lap in time, or other factors played into it, as Jenson pointed out.

"He believed he hadn’t made it. He immediately eased off the throttle. At that point, it’s too late; once a driver slows down, there's no use in advising them to accelerate again, because the chance to complete the lap has already slipped away. All these elements contributed to what happened. Still, I'd argue that the Ferrari pit crew had provided the necessary information.

In response to accusations of favouritism toward Hamilton, with former Aston Martin race strategist Collin supporting the team, the 15-time Grand Prix champion replied, "No."

He continued: "It's a complex situation. He’s not the first to have made such a mistake.

"But indeed, the timing line differs from the finish line. That’s something you should be aware of since the time displays on your dashboard. We are all made aware of our lap times as we cross that line. "

IGNORE THE DOUBT: OSCAR PIASTRI FACES TOUGHEST CHALLENGE OF CAREER

Jenson Button says the competitive F1 field in Las Vegas means "there's more to win and lose" for Oscar Piastri in his title fight with Lando Norris. A good weekend could close the 24-point gap.

top-news
Piastri Must Prove Title Maturity

As Oscar Piastri tries to entice Lando Norris, Jenson Button has emphasised that "there is more to win and lose" due to the competition at the pointy end of the Formula One grid at the Las Vegas Grand Prix.

In their quest for their first Formula One drivers' championship, the Australian driver is now 24 points behind his teammate.

He led Norris by a comfortable 34 points six rounds ago after the Dutch Grand Prix. However, a 58-point swing between the McLaren drivers has been caused by a lack of form and bad luck.

Piastri now needs to reduce the British driver's lead for the course of the weekend in Sin City with just three rounds left.

"Yes, and not just by a couple of points, either," Button stated on Sky Sports F1 before emphasising Piastri's serious risk on a weekend when the MCL39 is not anticipated to be the most competitive vehicle.

"There are a lot of competitive cars out there, so if he puts together a fantastic weekend, Oscar, he might steal a significant number of points from Lando. However, if Lando has a pleasant weekend, it might also go the other way.

"There is more to win and lose when there are more cars involved in fighting at the front, which is great for us, but it is much more stressful for them."

Addressing the issue, Button believes that Piastri has the right people on his side, notably manager Mark Webber, and that the nine-time grand prix winner is now making the necessary efforts to regain the form he had earlier in the season.

The 2009 F1 drivers' champion emphasised how he can get back into the title chase by facing his current issues head-on and relying on the experience of those around him.

"You know, it is hard. The former Williams, Benetton/Renault, BAR/Honda, and McLaren driver stated, "From what he claimed... There were tons of different concerns."

"In addition to mishaps, there are instances where a race is simply too slow. After seeing the data, he commented, "It is not great because you see where you are weaker than your teammate."

"But after you are done with it, you are much more confident because you can see where you are weak and, ideally, where you can become better.

"You also need wonderful individuals in your life. You need confidence-boosting people in your life. Mark Webber is his manager, which is advantageous.

"He has done that and been there. He has also experienced the challenges of nearly winning a world championship.

He has that experience, then. We will see whether he can take advantage of that. Whoever wins the championship does not matter to me.

"I just want to see a terrific battle till the very end, and it will be wonderful to see him coming back at Lando a little bit."

Premier League Standings

WhatsApp Read More News